preloader
  • Home >
  • Could
  • Could a roman legion defeat a medieval army?
  • Post:Stuart Morrison
  • 11/1/2021
  • Read 1839
  • Share:

Could a roman legion defeat a medieval army?

Looking for an answer to the question: Could a roman legion defeat a medieval army? On this page, we have gathered for you the most accurate and comprehensive information that will fully answer the question: Could a roman legion defeat a medieval army?

Was the Middle Ages really dark?

Many historians argued that the Early Middle Ages were actually not much darker than any other time period. Instead, this era evolved with its own political, social, economic and religious change. ... As a result, the church had a strong influence over the Early Middle Ages.


Who was the deadliest warrior of all time?

10 Of The Most Fearsome Warriors History Has Ever SeenShivaji Maharaj. © Indus library. ... Khutulun. © realmofhistory. ... Melankomas Of Caria. © listverse. ... The Flame. © listverse. ... Vlad The Impaler. © ancientorigins. ... Xiahou Dun. © YouTube. ... Pyrrhus of Epirus. © anestakos. ... Musashi Miyamoto. © steemit.


Were Romans more advanced than Middle Ages?

The Roman Empire was one of the most technologically advanced civilizations of antiquity, with some of the more advanced concepts and inventions forgotten during the turbulent eras of Late Antiquity and the early Middle Ages.


What was the most feared Roman Legion?

Legio IX Hispana Whilst, by the time of the death of Julius Caesar there were 37 Roman legions, here we are going to focus on 25 of the best know legions. According to the history of the Roman Empire, Legio IX Hispana was the most feared Roman Legion.


Was medieval times really that bad?

Not for nothing is the Medieval period often referred to as the ‘Dark Ages'. Not only was it incredibly gloomy, it was also quite a miserable time to be alive. Sure, some kings and nobles lived in relative splendor, but for most people, everyday life was dirty, boring and treacherous.


Was the 9th Legion Eagle ever found?

The Nijmegen finds, dating to c. 120, were, in 2015, the latest records of Legion IX found. The Ninth was apparently no longer in existence after 197.


When was the fall of Rome?

395 AD Fall of the Western Roman Empire/Start dates


Why Middle Ages is called Dark Ages?

The Middle Ages are often said to be dark because of a supposed lack of scientific and cultural advancement. During this time, feudalism was the dominant political system. ... Religious superstition was also widespread during this time.


Why were Romans so good in battle?

The reason why the Romans had such high resilience and grit is because of Roman society itself and especially, the desires of its nobility. ... It was their desires for these things that led the Romans not only to conquer the Hellenistic world but also to defeat the Carthaginian Empire and various other foes.


What happened to the 10th legion?

Legio X was famous in its day and throughout history, because of its portrayal in Caesar's Commentaries and the prominent role the Tenth played in his Gallic campaigns. Its soldiers were discharged in 45 BC. Its remnants were reconstituted, fought for Mark Antony and Octavian, disbanded, and later merged into X Gemina.


What were the Dark Ages of Christianity?

Vincent of Lérins's concept and more reasons for the orthodox to use Vincent's concept to exclude Unitarians, Deists, and other innovators from the circle of Christianity. In the 19th century philosophical and historical criticism inspired some Christians to renew the search for essences.


How many legions did Caesar have?

Unlike the mélange of loyalist troops, Caesar's nine legions were nearly all veterans, and many of them had fought for him in Gaul. On Caesar's left was Mark Antony with legions IX and VIII; because legion IX had suffered greatly at Dyrrhachium, the two legions were placed close together.


Who was the greatest Roman warrior?

Roman Leaders: The 10 Greatest Generals behind the EmpireMarcus Vipsanius Agrippa (63-12 BCE)Marcus Antonius (83-30 BCE) ... Gaius Julius Caesar (100-44 BCE) ... Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus (106-48 BCE) ... Lucius Cornelius Sulla (138-78 BCE) ... Gaius Marius (157-86 BCE) ... Scipio Africanus (236-183 BCE) ...


Who is the most feared warrior in history?

GREATEST WARRIORS OF ALL TIMEALEXANDER THE GREAT. Known as one of the greatest warriors ever, Alexander the Great was a renowned king too in an ancient Greek town. ... SPARTACUS. ... ASHOKA. ... JULIUS CAESAR. ... MAHARANA PRATAP. ... RICHARD THE LIONHEART. ... LEONIDAS OF SPARTA.


What was arianism Inquizitive?

Paul of Tarsus spread Christianity throughout the eastern Mediterranean. ... The Council of Nicea asserted that Arianism was heresy and defined an official Christian creed. Thinkers like Augustine, Boethius, and Benedict developed Christian theology and monastic practice.


What Roman legion went missing?

Legio IX Hispana ("9th Spanish Legion "), also written Legio VIIII Hispana, was a legion of the Imperial Roman army that existed from the 1st century BC until at least AD 120. ... The legion disappears from surviving Roman records after c. AD 120 and there is no extant account of what happened to it.


Do any Roman standards still exist?

An aquila (Classical Latin: [ˈakᶣɪla], "eagle") was a prominent symbol used in ancient Rome, especially as the standard of a Roman legion. ... No legionary eagles are known to have survived. However, other Roman eagles, either symbolizing imperial rule or used as funerary emblems, have been discovered.


Was Roman army Strong?

The Roman army started to have a full-time strength of 150,000 at all times and 3/4 of the rest were levied.


What was the most powerful Roman Legion?

1. Augusta Legion. What is this? Also known by the name Legio II Augusta, one can easily conclude that this famous legion got its cognomen from the legendary emperor of imperial Rome, Augustus himself.


How powerful was the Roman legion?

At its largest, there might have been around half a million soldiers in the Roman army! To keep such a large number of men in order, it was divided up into groups called 'legions'. Each legion had between 4,000 and 6,000 soldiers. ... He would also use it to beat any soldier who disobeyed him.

Could a roman legion defeat a medieval army? Video Answer

Threats to Roman Army Supply Lines and Logistics in Wartime

Could a roman legion defeat a medieval army? Expert Answers

Answeregy Expert
Bryant ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Are Romans medieval?

none

Answeregy Expert
Kay ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? - World …

Of course it could happen. A Roman legion could defeat a US heavy cavalry (i.e. tank) brigade, if the latter made enough mistakes. How many is enough? Well, in that case it’s enough to have all officers in question shot for incompetence, but it’s an extreme case. 14th century Europe? Not as extreme, but still pretty extreme.

Answeregy Expert
Kylee ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? - Quora

Yes. The typical legion had far more resources than a typical medieval army. The Roman legion was an excellent center and artillery corp. Auxiliaries, the other half of the Roman legion, included expert cavalry, slingers, an expert archer unit, etc.

Answeregy Expert
Lisa ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? - The Roman ...

https://www.quora.com/Could-a-Roman-legion-defeat-a-medieval-army/answer/Eric-Wang-434

Answeregy Expert
Aaron ⭐ Answeregy Expert

How well would a Roman army do against selected medieval ...

Nov 19, 2015. #9. I would guess that 1st century AD Roman armies would easily defeat any medieval army thanks to their superiority in doctrine, organization and logistics. I would think that any armed forces from 3000 BC to 1500 AD would be significantly inferior to the legions.

Answeregy Expert
Brentley ⭐ Answeregy Expert

In battle how would an Imperial Roman legion do against …

I get the Feeling than some of you don't know what makes up a 11th century European army. Hastings was brought up, so I get there too. The army oy William (no definite numbers known) is estimated around 7000+ (12.000?) men - probably half infantry, a quarter Archers and a quarter...

Answeregy Expert
Travion ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Top 8 Roman Military Defeats - ThoughtCo

Battle of the Allia (ca. 390–385 BCE) The Battle of the Allia (also known as the Gallic Disaster) was …

Answeregy Expert
Clark ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Would a Roman legion have been more successful at the ...

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? I am going to assume by Roman legion you mean the archetypical early imperial army. The Roman army took many forms including being almost indistinguishable from a Greek hoplite army to being almost indistinguishable from an …

Answeregy Expert
Gregory ⭐ Answeregy Expert

technology - Medieval army vs Legions- who would have the ...

If the battle took place in Roman times, the Romans could use their logistical advantage to sustain themselves, while depriving the Medieval army of supplies (they would have to get them from fortified Roman cities and military camps), while if a Roman Legion was operating in Medieval times, they would be the ones cut off from supplies and support.

Answeregy Expert
Brooke ⭐ Answeregy Expert

If there is a large battle between Roman legions and ...

If a full-fledged Roman legion (4000-5000 soldiers), with all the attached units (light infantry (2000–3000), two alae of cavalry (1000 riders), auxillaries and missile vehicles), altogether about 10 thousand of combatants, would meet with any medieval army of equal strength ( say, with the English of Edward or the Black Prince in their best ...

Answeregy Expert
Yaretzi ⭐ Answeregy Expert

How far into the Medieval Age could one Trajan era Roman ...

The Legions would probably do decently well against the Frankish army but start to suffer against William's Norman army. Maybe they could still achieve a 5/10 though. By the Crusades I'd say they start to lose the majority of battles.

Answeregy Expert
Devyn ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman Army vs Medieval armies - The History Forum

Now I would have to agree that the Roman Legions would have a great chance of victory over a medieval military force due to discipline, organization, numbers, and tactics. Most Medieval military forces lacked the discipline, tactics, and organization that was present among the Roman Legions. The key factor however is the leader.

Answeregy Expert
Darrel ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman army vs. a Medieval army? | Paradox Interactive Forums

The one critical factor is size. The armies of Rome, and the political organization to feed and supply that army over hundreds of miles of Roman road, would simply outnumber and outlast the meager forces that a Dark Ages or early Medieval army could field.

Answeregy Expert
Lana ⭐ Answeregy Expert

military - How quickly could the Roman legions march? How ...

The 'Raid March' practised by the French Foreign Legion requires a march of 75 miles in 3 days in full combat gear carrying rifle and 70 pounds of gear. A Full Pace march for a Roman Legionary in basic training required a march in daylight hours of 22 miles. Clearly it is entirely possible a Roman Legion could march 20-30 miles per day if needed.

Answeregy Expert
Ralph ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Dan Carlin claims that "You could take the roman army at ...

The multitudes of heavy infantry armed with heavy shields, a lorica segmentata, and a sturdy galea helm, were essentially invulnerable in melee combat, but, as evidenced by several notable Roman losses throughout the centuries, could be worn out and picked off by skirmisher cavalry.

Answeregy Expert
Alexis ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Could Alexander (the great) have defeated a Roman army ...

With good generals the legions were undefeatables, the roman army it`s very much flexible than Phalanx, in Granicus and Issus some good legions would had destroyed Alexander Army, in Gaugamela (in absolut flat place) Alexander would have win the battle. ... so he could even defeat the now days american army, it's the tactic what matters not the ...

Answeregy Expert
Ledger ⭐ Answeregy Expert

warfare - How could a medieval army defeat Sauron's army ...

I think a medieval army could pick small fights and pull back, pulling chunks of Sauron's army with it, into a battle that they are not supposed to be fighting. There would have to be disciplinarians in place just to keep its own army together, otherwise it would be like herding 75,000 cats across the country.

Answeregy Expert
Doris ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Would a Roman legion have been more successful at the ...

Our Roman Legion will of course follow Roman standing orders to entrench, so the Roman camp will look like this; An artist’s depiction of a Roman marching camp The battle began at around 11:00 AM, when a group of British scouts spotted and chased a handful of Zulu warriors, and subsequently found the entire Zulu Army sitting in complete ...

Answeregy Expert
Elaine ⭐ Answeregy Expert

How Could a Roman Legion Defeat a Tank? - YouTube

Today's new military battle is between two impossible opponents, but here at The Infographics Show we make the impossible possible. We're pitting the legionn...

Answeregy Expert
Carrie ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Knights vs Romans? — Ian Ross

The Roman army was based on the heavy infantry legion, developed to beat opponents who mainly fought on foot. The armies of the medieval era, on the other hand, were centred on the heavily armoured aristocratic knight, usually mounted before the 14th century, and supported by a …

Answeregy Expert
Gregory ⭐ Answeregy Expert

The Roman Legions: The Organized Military Force Of The ...

The Roman legions came to the forefront in the period of the Roman Republic . With each passing decade, it became increasingly obvious that the Roman army was involved in larger military operations and more frequently. Rome expanded its borders most often through warfare, and thus its army developed quickly and grew.

Answeregy Expert
Guillermo ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Would a roman army beat a medieval army?

Score: 4.9/5 (73 votes) . Ultimately, the Romans would almost certainly win a hand-to-hand, face-to-face fight, but Medieval warfare no longer revolved around that, and the heavy Knights and Longbowmen would likely make short work of the Legions before they could close for battle. View full answer In this manner, What was the strongest medieval army?

Answeregy Expert
Adonis ⭐ Answeregy Expert

why was the roman military so powerful - Lisbdnet.com

Could a Roman army beat a medieval army? Ultimately, the Romans would almost certainly win a hand-to-hand, face-to-face fight, but Medieval warfare no longer revolved around that, and the heavy Knights and Longbowmen would likely make short work of the Legions before they could close for battle.

Answeregy Expert
Lewis ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Are Romans medieval?

Ultimately, the Romans would almost certainly win a hand-to-hand, face-to-face fight, but Medieval warfare no longer revolved around that, and the heavy Knights and Longbowmen would likely make short work of the Legions before they could close for battle.

Answeregy Expert
Morris ⭐ Answeregy Expert

How effective would a Roman army from 1AD be against any ...

In fact, with serfdom coming into effect, they may be worse off in 1000AD. The Roman has better training, better equipment, and better tactics too. The only thing he lacks is contemporary technology. So, lets have a look at 1000AD military technology: At 1000AD, there would be cavalry yes, but the vast majority of the army would be peasant levies.

Answeregy Expert
Salman ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Did anyone try to replicate the Roman's military? : history

Medieval kingdoms would field smaller armies than Rome, of course, because there was not a single empire that controlled all the armies. A smaller army requires less organization. I believe a handful of Medieval knights would probably defeat a roman legion with little difficulty.

Answeregy Expert
Gladys ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Was the Roman army ever defeated? – JanetPanic.com

Could a Roman army beat a medieval army? Ultimately, the Romans would almost certainly win a hand-to-hand, face-to-face fight, but Medieval warfare no longer revolved around that, and the heavy Knights and Longbowmen would likely make …

Answeregy Expert
Hiram ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Who would win: Roman Legioneers or 1770s era army ...

Cannons and volley fire would destroy the Roman army. ElFenix Elite Member. Super Moderator. Mar 20, 2000 101,671 5,990 126. Feb 22, 2003 #10 roman soldiers weren't that well armored. ... heck, a single Abrams could kill all of the Roman legions without ammo

Answeregy Expert
Rodrigo ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman Army vs. Medieval Army | CivFanatics Forums

the roman army had the one ingredient that the medeival army lacked--discipline. Click to expand... not true, a knight spent their whole life training, and they were mounted, a medieval army could beat a legion. Wars may be fought with weapons, but they are won by men.

Answeregy Expert
Bernard ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Were the ancient Roman armies more effective than medieval ...

The Roman army of Trajan would have crushed any medieval army, for one basic reason: the Roman army, unlike the levies and knights called together by medieval kings, was a professional fighting force. Its armies had training and - more importantly - financial and …

Answeregy Expert
Lee ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Could a Marine platoon defeat a whole Roman Legion? - YouTube

Play War Thunder for free on PC, PlayStation®4 and Xbox One! Support Binkov and click here to get a free aircraft, tank or a ship; and three days of premium ...

Answeregy Expert
Analisa ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Did the Roman Army have medics? - The Roman Empire

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? So, how to answer this question and when exactly DID the Middle Ages start? With the conversion of Rome to Christianity? Somewhat later when the barbarian armies stormed the West, at the begining of the C5th or near the end of the century with the death of Aetius “last of the Romans” or with the ...

Answeregy Expert
Sharon ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Could medieval soldiers be organized into a Roman style ...

Is there any reason why medieval soldiers could not have been organized into the order of battle of the Roman Empire by a ruler or empire that chose to do so? Integrating crossbowmen, longbowmen,

Answeregy Expert
Sara ⭐ Answeregy Expert

What if: Roman legions vs medieval European army - World ...

27 Mar 13,, 00:23. This generalization: On average, the roman soldier was better trained and lead than his medieval counterpart, but the later enjoyed the advantage of better armor, weapons, and a complete superiority in mounted warfare. often proves unreliable since Knights (at least those raised in nobility) were trained often as early as mid ...

Answeregy Expert
Cale ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman Legions vs The French Army at Agincourt | SpaceBattles

Given that the Romans wouldn't have had the advantage of massed longbows that the English possessed at the historical battle of Agincourt, I've decided to give the Romans 15,600 full time, Lorica Segmentata, Pilla, and Gladius equipped Legionaries (3 Early Imperial Legions, at 5,200 Legionaries a Legion), supported by roughly 5,000 Germanic and ...

Answeregy Expert
Henry ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman Army vs. Medieval Army | Page 8 | CivFanatics Forums

For it's possible to pick a time when the Roman army was weak and a Medieval Army was strong and slant the results. Actually, in truth, any Medieval Army after 1350 would totally defeat the Romans. All it would take is a plague victim to cough on the Romans, and they would drop like flies.

Answeregy Expert
Janis ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman Army vs. Medieval Army | Page 4 | CivFanatics Forums

a medievel army no quistion. there armor and weapondry was far more effective, not to mention the longbow (would have slaughtered roman legions). Alot of barbarian armies at the time could have beat a roman legion, the huns on horesback and barbarian tribes with axemen were more effective.

Answeregy Expert
Ivan ⭐ Answeregy Expert

What ways can an army defeat a Roman Phalanx/Testudo ...

In the days of the early Roman republic, the army was first utilizing the Greek phalanx. The Romans improved upon the phalanx design and it evolved into the legion. A Roman legion was made of of ten cohorts, with six lines of 80 soldiers each, called centuries. Each cohort could break off …

Answeregy Expert
Noelle ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman legion vs Norman army from 1066 | History Forum

Roman. -A legion, during Pax Romana, consisted of approximately 5,120 legionaries and the same number of auxiliaries, for a total of around 10,000+ men. 59 ballistae and 10 onagers would be attached to a legion as well. Auxiliary bowmen, slingers, and cavalry would be present along with auxiliary infantry but I cannot find numbers on how this ...

Answeregy Expert
Anglea ⭐ Answeregy Expert

could 10,000 english longbowmen defeat 50,000 roman ...

9,749. Malaysia. Nov 16, 2021. #47. Well, if it were me commanding a 10,000-strong longbowman army, contemplating taking on a 50,000-strong Roman legionnaire army, I would make darn sure first that my army conducts loads & loads of shooting practice well beforehand. Using authentic Roman shields that we have gathered.

Answeregy Expert
Sylvia ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman Army vs. Medieval Army | Page 3 | CivFanatics Forums

This is an old thread but it interests me somewhat. I think the Romans would most likely have decimated any medieval army bar the Mongols. A Roman legion from Caesar's time normally consisted of over five thousand elite heavy infantry, plus again that many auxiliary troops, including spears, cavalry, and skirmishers (the tactic of supporting the main infantry with several groups of more …

Answeregy Expert
Brandy ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Roman Army vs. Medieval Army | Page 2 | CivFanatics Forums

A Dark Age army (Carolingian era) or even an 11th century army (Senlac Hill, etc.) would find the Roman legions to be more than a match. It was only during the dawn of the Renaissance (started in the late 14th - early 15th century) when military technology saw a massive improvement in arms (the bodkin arrow, etc.) and organisation.

Answeregy Expert
Tayler ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Rome vs Medieval armies - Page 6 — Total War Forums

To say that a medieval army consisted out of untrained peasants and knights is very ignorant. While these medieval armies could beat and perhaps easily a beat a roman legion it could not sustain itself. Concerns at home meant that medieval army could rarely campaign for 10 years straight.

Answeregy Expert
Thais ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Romans in Britain - Roman Artillery

During the Roman Republic and early empire eras, 60 scorpio per legion was the standard, or one for every centuria. The scorpio had mainly two functions in a legion: in tended shooting, it was a weapon of marksmanship capable of cutting down any foe within a distance of 100 meters.

Answeregy Expert
Rylee ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Armored Legionnaires cannot defeat a Oathsworn?!!! - Page ...

Welcome . Please register for Total War Access to use the forums. If you're an existing user, your forum details will be merged with Total War Access if you register with the same email or username.

Answeregy Expert
Jordan ⭐ Answeregy Expert

Armored Legionnaires cannot defeat a Oathsworn?!!! - Page ...

Welcome . Please register for Total War Access to use the forums. If you're an existing user, your forum details will be merged with Total War Access if you register with the same email or username.

Used Resourses:

About Author
Answeregy Author

Stuart Morrison

Hi everyone, my name is Stuart Morrison and I am the editor-in-chief and author of the Answeregy website. I am 35 years old and live in Miami, Florida. From an early age I loved to learn new things, constantly reading various encyclopedias and magazines. In 1998 I created my first Web site, where I posted interesting facts which you could rarely learn elsewhere. Then, it led me to work as a content manager for a large online publication. I always wanted to help people while doing something I really enjoyed. That's how I ended up on the Answeregy.com team, where I... Read more